Adding this to the list of things Erin hates, such as freedom, love, puppies, and the environment. Who hates Phil? Anyways, conversation that transpired, plus some objective third party opinions:

Erin: genesis
makes my skin CRAWL
sick
me: so good.
SO good.
phil, i love you
Erin: so rough
i loathe him
did i tell you how my ex had a Phillow

Ian: who doesn’t love phil collins?
tell her to go back to russia.

Katie: hahaha
how can she not like phil?
that is like a sin of some sort

Erin: ive hated phil since i was born
i cant help it
its the sound of his voice
makes me want to end it

Ian: i’m not his #1 fan or anything, but all of his hits rule.
i can see not liking him (MAYBE), but hating him so bad you want to kill yourself? sounds like she lives in musical purgatory.